Bing Imagery Misaligned at Lower Zooms

Microsoft’s Bing aerial imagery (that’s recently been donated to OSM for use in tracing) is offset by a few meters in some places.

For example, earlier this week I traced buildings with imagery from USDA’s NAIP program. Besides a history of being well-rectified, a GPS track in the parking lot confirms that I was spot on. However, on Bing with a low zoom, they’re misaligned:

Zoom in a bit, and they magically align again:

Apparently, different, well-rectified imagery is used at higher zooms. If I’ve found one problem, it then follows that it exists elsewhere. Be careful when tracing!

Like this article? Please support my writing! Flattr my blog (see my thoughts on Flattr), tip me via PayPal, or send me an item from my Amazon wish list.

Comments

Jean-Marc Liotier's picture

Thank you for the warning - I tested Potlach 2 and the Bing imagery yesterday, and I realigned a couple of streets based on the Bing imagery… If you are right, that might have been a misguided move. I’ll see how it correlates with GPS and other sources.

You might want to take that to the talk@osm mailing list for more feedback.

Anonymous Visitor's picture

I used to align objects (surveyed during the day) accordingly to Yahoo satellite. Now I’m going to redo them with Bing’s highest zoom. When zooming out, Bing is well aligned in my region with both Yahoo and practically all existing roads and points. When zooming in, I can make the objects more detailed.

Thanks to Bing for allowing to use its satellite imagery… It doesn’t know what to do with the imagery, that’s why it has to share it with others.

Anonymous Visitor's picture

J’ai verifié en France sur les certaines zones côtières entre BING et GEOLITTORAL ou le CADASTRE. L’écart est confirmé.

GEOLITTORAL+CADASTRE=YES mais BING+CADASTRE=NO

adminl's picture
Rough translation: confirmed along coastal areas in France.